Commack, NY

Mayfair Bagel Cafe

Fresh bagels, avocado toasted eggs, and a Boar’s Head counter in Commack.

Get directions

Monday – Sunday, 6:00 AM – 4:00 PM

Bagel wall with sesame, everything, and salt bagels

Hot out of the oven

About

The Commack shop

Mayfair Bagel Cafe is the Commack shop at Mayfair Shopping Center. The bagel wall is stacked every morning, eggs get toasted to order, and avocado toast sits next to lox, whitefish, and house salads in the case. Boar’s Head is sliced at the counter for signature sandwiches like the New Yorker. Huntington, Smithtown, and the rest of the North Shore are a short drive.

From the counter

Morning favorites

01
Avocado Toasted Eggs
Smashed avocado and toasted eggs on a fresh bagel — the morning order from the counter.
02
Toasted Egg Sandwich
Eggs toasted to order, cheese, and the bagel you pick. Add Boar’s Head bacon or sausage.
03
Lox
Nova lox from the case, cream cheese, tomato, and onion on a toasted bagel.
04
The New Yorker
A Bagel Toasterie signature sandwich from the board — piled at the Boar’s Head counter.
05
Chicken Salad
House chicken salad scooped from the case. Also tuna, whitefish, and egg salad.
06
House Spreads
Jalapeño, strawberry, cinnamon raisin walnut, chocolate chip, and olive — scooped on the bagel you want.